Research shows that the year an election is held has the biggest impact on voter turnout on the local level. In the largest U.S. cities, voter turnout for mayor is 2.3 times higher when elections coincide with presidential elections rather than being held off-cycle. In New York City - which, like all cities in the state, holds its election in odd-numbered years - voter turnout for mayor has steadily declined, with the most recent election reaching a record-low 23% turnout. Moving local elections to even-numbered years dramatically increases voter participation up and down the ballot—often doubling turnout in mayoral races.

Additionally, off-cycle elections disproportionately suppress turnout among young voters and voters of color, leading to a less representative electorate. Moving local elections to even-numbered years reduces participation gaps and ensures that more New Yorkers have a voice in the elections that shape their daily lives.